Thursday, February 6, 2014

Post #1 why using survival skills in a SHTF is stupid.


I have just started a youtube channel about similar subject matter and am creating this blog to discuss the same subject I've been thinking about. you can check out my channel here https://www.youtube.com/user/rocksthetrail So who am I and what made me come to the conclusion that planning on using survival skills in a SHTF situation is stupid? I have been practicing wilderness survival and primitive living skills for 16 years. I began as a child learning at a primitive living skills summer camp I went on to work as a counselor there teaching wilderness survival and primitive living skills. I went on to work as a wilderness field instructor for a wilderness therapy program that focused on primitive living skills and self sufficiency both for practical applications and as a mind set. I made it to being a master wilderness field instructor, the highest level of instructors. I have spent a total of 4 years or around 1,460 nights sleeping in the woods. While I never worked for BOSS or Tom Brown school I believe my experience has given me a solid base to understand wilderness survival skills. I am confident in my ability to survive with nothing more than some decent clothes on my back, a knife and a metal water bottle. I stopped working as a field instructor last April and am currently working as a mental health professional. I am engaged to be married this summer and plan on starting a family in the near future. As such the option to bug out and live in the woods is no longer an option. As I have begun my journey to being prepared some I have done some rethinking of my previous plan for a SHTF situation and seen that it was based more on my ego and attempts to derive identity from my wilderness survival skills rather than logical or practical. Often when my students asked me what I would do in a SHTF situation I would reply with something involving bugging out to a wilderness location, living off the land setting up traps for the "zombies" or other intruders and limiting myself to a .22 rifle for hunting and protection. This was based more in fantasy than reality. While I am confident that if I needed to right now I could go out into the woods with minimal supplies and survive for an indefinite period. However survive is the key word here, I would be in a constant state of survival. looking for food, building a camp etc. would consume all of my time. The more supplies I would bring out with me the easier go at it i'd have. I've carried a 90 pound bag over glaciers in Patagonia, it sucks, and that's pretty much my limit. my car can hold even more and my house even more than that. even If I were to build on awesome camp where I was relatively comfortable there is no way it would be a defensible as my home with equal amounts of time and effort put into security and hey I can start working on home security now, I don't have to weight for SHTF to go off into the woods and starting building something from tree branches and cordage. point #1 even if you have the skills to survive in the wilderness most of you time initial time is going to be spent on thing that can easily be stored in a house. Ok so lets imagine SHTF, how many people have similar ideas that I did? A lot and the wilderness survival industry tends to perpetuate these ideas. lets take a quick look at Tom Brown, I loved his books when I was getting into wilderness survival, however sometimes he writes things like we found a nice spot to spend the night, in two hours we had debris huts constructed, built a bowdrill from scratch and were about to roast the two rabbits our dead fall traps had caught (not an actual quote but he states similar things a lot in his books). I thought wow if I really learn these skills I'll be able to do that. WRONG. I don't care who you are or how fast you are with you skills in summer the fastest I have ever made a debris hut is around 5 hours, I can construct a bow drill set and get a fire going normally in 1-2 hours if the woods relatively dry otherwise, sure I've busted a coal in 8 seconds but that was with a set that I spent way longer than 2 hours constructing. As far as traps go to catch 2 rabbits, especially using natural bait your probably going to need well over 100 traps. Just setting these up is going to take you at least 2 hours and that is if you have the traps already made and can find a good location, lots of signs of small game, find a good sized rock and get your trap up all in just a little over 1 minute. So Tom Brown has magic survival skills that gives newer survivalist an unrealistic picture of what it means to survive. In my experience most simulated survival situation involve a good amount of being hungry and cold. Now who knows what the wilderness is gonna be like post event, lots of refugee and not too much food. Even if you can survive in the woods now does not mean you will be able to post event. we just don't know whats going to happen and how the country will respond. more to come later

No comments:

Post a Comment